Neptune does not lie, it removes the edge. Ranked by sign, here is how hard each Neptune placement is to pin down — and the exact sentence you will hear when you corner one.
Pisces men are possessive in a way nobody warns you about: they don't want to own you, they want to keep you from meeting the other half of them. Pisces is a bicorporeal sign, Neptune rules his seventh house of partnership, and that combination explains the devotion, the vanishing and the interrogation about the week you were fine without him.
Psyche in Pisces falls in love with the version of a man it wrote itself, then spends years defending that draft against his actual behaviour. Every month you describe what he could be is a month you are not being loved by who he is, and you are the one paying for it.
Pisces men are possessive rather than jealous: they don't need to know where you are, they need to be the only person who knows you. Venus exalted in Pisces, Neptune's fog and a Mars with no ground to stand on explain the silence, the 2am essay and the guilt.
You cannot make a Pisces woman jealous, and the attempt costs you the relationship in a way you will not notice for months. Her Sun is ruled by Neptune, which dissolves rather than competes, so jealousy never arrives as a fight. It arrives as fog, then as a quiet goodbye.
Neptune in Cancer makes you homesick for a home that never existed. Why you keep choosing the fantasy over reality, what it costs you, and how to finally close the loop.